Heart of Winter Reviews: Ciele Athletics, Brooks, and Ibex "Super" Vests and More!

Article by Sam Winebaum

Ibex Wool-Aire Vest ($235), Ciele Athletics OTF Insulator ($280), Brooks Run Seen Vest ($160)

There’s nothing like an insulated vest for versatility. Along with your core wind protected, and heat, layering under and over turns into a matter of selection given the circumstances. All three of our examined vests for certain fulfill that mission, are very mild for the heat they supply and have state-of-the-art insulation. But, every goes about it in very other ways. All examined samples are males’s medium. I’m 5’9” tall and weigh 167 lbs. All three have been examined in circumstances from the mid 40’s F all the way down to the excessive teenagers in New Hampshire and Utah on form of “runs” extra like quick walks as I’m rehabbing a damaged knee cap.

Ibex Wool-Aire Vest ($235)

Greatest for: Single vest to do all of it. Run, hike, round city

Professionals

lightest, warmest

proprietary 80% wool mix insulation: fast drying. anti microbial

most acceptable fashion for on a regular basis use

3 deep pockets for storage and air flow

Cons

lengthy and a bit looser becoming than others

small, finicky, probably fragile predominant zipper

costly

The Wool-Aire Vest combines a extra sustainable 80% wool insulation with a wind and flippantly waterproof outer shell. Ibex was one of many authentic sport merino firms. I’ve owned and examined attire from them for many years most lately testing the Wool-Aire Hoodie which is actually the Vest with sleeves and a hood. Its efficiency has been excellent and it has remained my goto “puffy” for its unbelievable weight to insulation ratio and fast drying. I used to be keen to check the Vest because it promised to supply better run and hike versatility in all seasons.

At 200 g in my medium it’s the lightest vest right here by a substantial margin. It options 3 deep pockets: 2 facet and one chest for storage and likewise for air flow.

The match is true to my common medium and on the beneficiant facet each in size and total match. Partly this is because of how mild and straightforward it matches. I typically was struck by its distinctive mixture of ethereal lightness, and breathability (typically questioning if I used to be truly carrying a vest in any respect) but with simply the proper heat and loads of wind safety

Efficiency is great particularly when have paired it with Ibex Woolies Professional-Tech Lengthy Sleeve ($115), a stretchy comfortable 85% merino prime made with Nuyarn spinning expertise that makes merino 35% extra thermally environment friendly, 85% extra elastic, and eight.8x extra sturdy than its ring-spun counterparts.

The mix is about as efficient but luxuriously snug a run mixture as I’ve skilled. I by no means had a sensation the vest grew to become a sweat field throughout greater output actions

I are inclined to want non kind match attire in winter to permit motion and an air pocket between outer and internal layers for breathability/moisture transmission and thus heat as a moist runner is a chilly runner in winter. Right here now we have the proper vest for that as one can open the pockets for but extra air flow, put a shell over it or in a variety of circumstances simply use it over a mid layer such because the Professional-Tech.

I want to see a extra substantial entrance zipper because the small one is finicky and probably fragile. The Wool-Aire at $235 is expensive. That stated, this vest with a extra sustainable wool twist is an outstanding mixture of sunshine weight, excessive performing insulation and go wherever styling.

Ciele Athletics OTF Insulator ($280)

Greatest for: Air flow on the go and making a excessive efficiency and distinctive fashion assertion

Professionals:

Polartec Alpha insulation may be very heat for weight and fast drying

versatile, many makes use of

snaps as an alternative of zip enable plenty of customized air flow

loads of discrete “black out” reflective parts

stands out. Why not sleeves! Why not baseball jersey fashion!

reversible for a really wild look

Cons

Ciele of Montreal, Canada is thought for its fashionable colourful excessive efficiency run caps. Right here they delve into insulated attire with a novel fashion twist: a baseball styled brief sleeve insulated shirt full with snap entrance and knit sort neck.

It’s reversible with my All Over Tile-Whitaker shade having a wild black and white internal sample material.

The OFT is meant for variable winter circumstances, pre and publish run heat and wind safety and may be simply layered beneath a shell. Given it provides insulated sleeves to basically what’s a vest it weighs the a lot of the three at 309 g.

The OFT is insulated with Polartec Alpha, a fabric initially developed for US Particular Forces who specified very mild weight, breathability and fast drying. I’ve examined a number of jackets with Alpha and it for certain delivers as specified and does so right here with a light-weight ethereal really feel on the physique akin to the Wool-Aire. One a warmish day within the 40’s I wore it with a brief sleeve T and it was excellent combo.

As an alternative of the same old zipper up entrance the OFT has snaps which permit for extremely custom-made air flow on the go.

Reflective parts illuminated with a headlamp

There are two deep facet considerably excessive zip pockets whose banding is reflective together with 2 skinny reflective black out bands on the sleeves with a reflective strip and brand on the again. Whereas black shouldn’t be a excessive distinction shade (a white OFT is accessible) Ciele included loads of discrete in daylight, night time security parts

Reflective parts illuminated with a headlamp

In contrast to the Wool-Aire and just like the Brooks Run Seen Vest, there’s a strip of ventilating stretch mesh down the middle prime of the again.

The match is true to my dimension medium and as with the Wool Aireit rests mild and straightforward on the chest and right here additionally arms.

Efficiency has been wonderful. As with the Wool-Aire, the match is mild and straightforward on the physique, no stretch match vest right here. Wind safety is prime notch and the Alpha insulation heat and breathable and surprisingly so given how skinny it’s however what I’ve come to count on from Polartec Alpha. And, because it warms, the a number of snaps opening of the entrance ( permits for as a lot air flow as you may want with the shirt format maintaining it in your shoulders.

Together with the OFT Ciele additionally despatched the MSFT Tight and CW BKTHat ($80), a tackle their summer time buckets with the identical tremendous ethereal and comfortable CoolMatic material however including a heat stretch fleece headband and ear flaps (non detachable) to the within.

It has confirmed the proper excessive altitude solar defending hat with heat in Park Metropolis and its massive brim stored the snow off my glasses in a severe sudden squall!

The 60 cm giant dimension match my bigger dimension head fairly snuggly initially, particularly with the ear flaps folded however stretched to suit after just a few makes use of.

It has a shock wire to tighten and I believe Ciele may improve the diameter of the big and make higher use of the shock wire as it’s all the way in which out flaps down or up.

Not often a good type of runner, I want nordic fashion run pants, the MSFTight ($130) have confirmed the exception to the rule. The comfortable stretchy luxurious materials doesn’t hold my knees from truly lifting as many tights do.

It has an outstanding safe waistband that’s not over comfortable and with no sag on the rear.

Two tremendous deep thigh pockets are nice for any cellphone, gloves, hat and keys. The whole lot stays properly safe on account of their depth and stretch material.

The OFT styling is to make sure not the same old and pricing may be very steep however this nicely thought out versatile “shirt” is nicely price consideration as are the tights and bucket. Totally different for certain however efficient and excessive performing!

Brooks Run Seen Insulated Vest ($160)

Greatest for: Day and night time on the street run visibility

Professionals

Cons

The Brooks Run Seen is “clearly” targeted totally on run security given its contrasting shiny white and optic yellow with black within the combine materials together with intensive blackout 3M reflective parts throughout. With science behind it, the insulated vest is designed to focus on the physique in movement in all mild circumstances. At 279g it’s the second heaviest vest.

The vest consists of two gigantic entrance zip pockets- useful for telephones, gloves, hats and extra. One pocket consists of an internal sleeve to safe a cellphone though I by no means felt I wanted it because the match right here is trimmer and extra slim than the opposite choices however with first rate size.

The zipper is stout with 2 snaps to carry the vest in place if unzipped

Vest illuminated with a headlamp: silvery areas are black when not illuminated

The higher black and optic yellow areas are insulated in “puffy” fashion diagonal bands with a middle again a breathable non insulated space.

The decrease areas are very wind resistant and fairly breathable with the pockets’ entrance facet lined with a grid mesh for a contact extra entrance insulation. I discovered the outer clean shell to be commendably waterproof though it’s not waterproof.

The Run Seen Insulated Vest clearly has a purpose-keep you seen on the run in all mild circumstances. It does so admirably nicely if in “brighter vogue” than the opposite vests, possibly limiting its makes use of relying in your fashion preferences. Personally I like its shiny and cheery vibe!

The insulation and air flow may be very strong however as a slimmer becoming vest with a smoother extra waterproof outer shell it’s not as ethereal mild and nearly invisible in really feel as the opposite pricier vests right here. As a pure run insulated vest it’s the most sensible selection and is significantly cheaper than the others.

Backside Line

Ibex Wool Aire- the sunshine and heat, do something, go wherever “outside” styled possibility.

Ciele OFT Insulator – the versatile, “completely different” and pattern setting possibility

Brooks Run Seen Insulated Vest- security targeted, purposeful and shiny, the very best worth.

Sam is the Editor and Founding father of Street Path Run. He’s 66 with a 2018 3:40 Boston qualifier. 2022 was Sam’s fiftieth 12 months of working. He has a a long time previous 2:28 marathon PR. Nowadays he runs halves within the simply sub 1:40 vary if he will get very very fortunate. Sam trains 30-40 miles per week largely at reasonable paces on the roads and trails of New Hampshire and Utah be it on the run, mountain climbing or on nordic skis. He’s 5’9” tall and weighs about 164 lbs, if he’s not having fun with too many effective New England IPA’s.

Samples have been supplied at no cost for evaluation functions. RoadTrail Run has affiliate partnerships and should earn fee on merchandise bought through buying hyperlinks on this article. These partnerships don’t affect our editorial content material. The opinions herein are completely the authors’.

Feedback and Questions Welcome Beneath! Please tell us mileage, paces, race distances, and present most popular footwear

RoadTrailRun Official Retailer Customized Fractel Caps and Bucket Hats