Wind tunnel tested – 18 road bike wheelsets go head to head

In the case of upgrades on your bike, there are few as thrilling as a brand new set of wheels. They will make a motorcycle quicker, lighter, higher dealing with, extra satisfying to trip, and let’s face it, deep aero wheels simply look cool. 

However in the event you’re trying to improve, how do you select the best pair of wheels on your bike? 

After all, there are compatibility considerations that you will want to beat to make sure the wheels you select will truly suit your bike, however past these, as in all walks of life, the reply is: “it relies upon.”

Your essential motivation for a brand new set of wheels will in all probability since you need to go quicker, however there are a number of elements that mix to make one wheelset higher or worse than one other, and the significance of these elements will rely upon the kind of terrain you may be driving on. 

When driving uphill, it is a truthful assumption {that a} lighter wheelset will make you quicker, however for in every single place else – downhill, on the flat, and even on slight uphill gradients – a extra aerodynamic wheelset will profit you extra. 

Because of this, manufacturers are sometimes eager to level out the aerodynamic credentials of their new launch. It is uncommon to see a brand new wheelset launched with out some form of declare that it could prevent X watts towards the outdated mannequin, or Y seconds over an arbitrary time trial distance. 

These claims are good to have, however though some manufacturers have gotten extra clear about their testing strategies, we nonetheless must take every declare with a grain of salt. In any case, advertising departments will not need to inform you if their product is slower, will they?

That is the place we are available! Over the previous 12 months, we have been taking one of the best merchandise in numerous classes right into a wind tunnel ourselves, testing them face to face with one another to see that are quickest. 

We have wind-tunnel examined highway wheels earlier than, however as a part of our rising sequence of lab-based assessments, we wished to revisit that with a extra thorough and up-to-date take a look at with extra wheels, extra testing speeds, and a little bit of further knowledge alongside. 

So final week, we took 18 wheelsets to the Silverstone Sports activities Engineering Hub, the world-renowned testing facility utilized by producers, professionals and WorldTour groups alike. We additionally weighed and measured every wheelset to offer a extra full image of that are one of the best in the marketplace proper now. 

Earlier than we get into the information, a fast interlude to say this text contains paid product placement from Schwalbe and Reap Bikes. I personally accepted their inclusion, having agreed they’d supply no unfair bias, nor the looks of bias, to any of the wheels on take a look at. Neither of which had any enter into the take a look at protocol or the outcomes. 

We paid the identical charge that any member of the general public would pay for using the wind tunnel and borrowed all the things used on this take a look at. With out our subscribers, these assessments can’t occur, and so a good and neutral protocol is crucial to their success and the power to proceed doing them.

The wheels

We took numerous wheelsets – someplace within the area of 25 – plus a baseline shallow wheelset to check towards, and though we ran out of time to check all the things we took, we efficiently obtained by means of 18 assessments, that are listed beneath. 

Our intention was to have a collection of mid-depth wheelsets throughout a broad worth spectrum, masking people who on a regular basis cyclists could also be trying to purchase in addition to premium wheelsets which are extra within the when-I-win-the-lottery class. We additionally wished to replicate wheels discovered within the WorldTour peloton. 

We opted for the highest-spec wheelset from every model the place obtainable. Some have been unable to get us the very top-spec mannequin, corresponding to Campagnolo, which despatched the Bora WTO quite than the marginally extra premium Bora Extremely WTO. 

It is value including that the majority manufacturers supply a extra budget-friendly various to the wheelsets we have examined right here. 

In alphabetical order, the wheels we examined are as follows: 

Black Inc 48/58Black Inc 62Cadex 50 UltraCampagnolo Bora WTO 60Enve SES 4.5Enve SES 6.7Hunt Sub 50 LimitlessParcours StradePrinceton Carbonworks Wake 6560 EvolutionReserve 52/63Roval Rapide CLX IIScope Artech 6.AScribe Core SuperLight 60Shimano Dura Ace C50Swiss Facet Hadron Final 500Syncros Capital SL AeroVision Metron 60 SLZipp 404 FirecrestPlus our baseline: Fulcrum Racing 5

Just like utilizing the Trek Emonda ALR as a baseline in our wind tunnel superbike take a look at, we wished an entry-level product within the take a look at for a few causes. 

Firstly, we wished not solely to indicate the distinction between Fancy Wheelset 1 and Fancy Wheelset 2, however how these wheelsets differed from a low-cost possibility. 

Secondly, we expect the Fulcrum Racing 5 is a standard instance of a contemporary finances wheelset, and in the event you’re studying this with a view to upgrading, there is a good probability you could have an identical set by yourself bike. Subsequently, it affords a good suggestion of how a lot you are prone to acquire when upgrading. 

We additionally intention to take the Fulcrum Racing 5 again to the tunnel in future assessments to offer a continuing comparability. 

As for the take a look at wheelsets, we have been restricted to a degree by what we may get our palms on. We depend on manufacturers’ goodwill to lend them to us, and most manufacturers imagine of their product sufficient, and belief our impartiality sufficient, to agree. 

Nonetheless, generally, issues do not work out. For instance, we requested wheels from Fulcrum, Corima, Winspace, Light-weight and others, however our requests both went unanswered, or logistical difficulties (aka sluggish couriers and overzealous customs controls) stopped play. 

We additionally took alongside some Zipp 808 Firecrest wheels to see how a lot further may very well be gained by switching to even deeper wheels, however sadly ran out of time earlier than we may take a look at them. Subsequent time!

The take a look at

As with earlier assessments, we took the wheelsets to the wind tunnel on the Silverstone Sports activities Engineering Hub, and we examined the aerodynamic efficiency of every wheelset. 

That is measured in Coefficient of Drag x Space (CdA), and is quantified in metres squared. To briefly clarify the 2 components, the Coefficient of Drag defines how simply air passes over an merchandise’s floor, and is influenced by its form in addition to the fabric on its floor. Space is kind of merely a measure of the merchandise’s dimension; the larger one thing is, the extra wind it hits because it strikes by means of the air, and the much less aerodynamic it’s (all else being equal). 

Finally our major intention was to seek out out that are the quickest, and what kind of financial savings you’ll be able to count on to make by upgrading from a nominally common wheelset to a go-faster carbon fibre aero wheelset. 

From that, we will additionally derive whether or not upgrading your wheels is an effective value-for-money determination when in comparison with different obtainable upgrades. Coupled with our wind tunnel helmet take a look at, our wind tunnel superbike take a look at, our rolling resistance tyre take a look at, and the entire upcoming lab assessments we have in planning, we need to assist our readers resolve the place to spend their cash first in an effort to get quicker… properly, quicker!

Signal as much as the Musette – our subscriber-only e-newsletter

Every knowledge seize was carried out in five-degree increments from -15 to +15 levels of yaw, the angle at which the wind hits the bike. Meaning seven seize factors at -15, -10, -5, 0, +5, +10 and +15 levels. Every seize was carried out in a sweep in the identical course (unfavorable to constructive) for consistency. 

We carried out this sweep for every wheelset at three speeds: 30kph, 40kph and 50kph. We all know that some wheelsets carry out higher than others at decrease speeds, whereas others sail, utilizing the wind to create elevate and supply ahead propulsion, as speeds improve. The earlier this occurs, the higher a wheel is prone to be for on a regular basis riders. To seize knowledge at one velocity and extrapolate from there would miss this important distinction and supply inaccurate outcomes. For an instance of this, maintain a watch out for the outcomes of the Princeton wheels beneath, and the way their positions within the rankings enhance at greater speeds. 

This implies a complete of 21 CdA measurements per wheelset, or 399 measurements in whole when together with our baseline wheelset. 

We then used this knowledge to calculate the watts required to propel the bike on the three given speeds, utilizing the system beneath. That is for comparative functions alone, we all know bikes can’t pedal themselves!

Energy (watts) = 0.5 x AirDensity x CdA x Velocity^3

Protocol & standardisations

The take a look at was standardised, that means the identical circumstances have been met for every wheelset throughout every knowledge seize. These included the bike, the wind velocity, the tyres, disc rotors, cassettes and extra. 

Prior to every take a look at, the wind tunnel underwent a taring course of, related in precept to the tare in your kitchen scales or zero-offsetting your energy meter to make sure correct readings.

Every wheelset was mounted to the identical bike: a Reap Vekta in dimension 56cm. Our stipulation right here was to make use of a motorcycle that had no affinity to any of the wheel manufacturers in query, and Reap was a superb match with aerodynamics at its forefront. A Specialised Tarmac, for instance, would have been designed along with the Roval wheels and will, in flip, create an unfair benefit to these wheels. Likewise, a Large Propel may unfairly profit the Cadex wheels, Cervélo with Reserve, and so forth.

We examined utilizing the bike alone, with out a rider current, however with the wheels spinning on the applicable velocity. After we beforehand examined wheels in 2022, we first did some preliminary assessments the place we examined a number of wheelsets with a rider, after which once more with out a rider. The variations between every wheelset have been the identical in each assessments, however to seize the information with the rider current, we would have liked longer captures and it launched extra variability because of the potential motion of the rider. Having discovered the identical outcomes with improved statistical confidence in much less time, it was a no brainer to proceed with out a rider, and so we took the identical strategy this time spherical too. 

Every wheelset was fitted with a 28mm Schwalbe Professional One TLE tyre. A few of the wheels on the take a look at have been designed round a 25mm tyre, so we’ll observe these beneath the place related. 

For cleanliness and ease, we used inside tubes, and we used tubes with a valve of the shortest useful size. We wished to imitate what riders will truly use in the actual world, quite than doubtlessly skew the information for shallower wheels with ungainly 80mm valves within the identify of standardisation. 

Every wheelset was fitted with equivalent Shimano Dura-Ace disc rotors and a Shimano 105 cassette.

Tyres have been inflated to between 50 and 60psi, guided by the SRAM tyre strain calculator based mostly on inside rim widths and whether or not they have been hooked or hookless.

Every wheel was checked earlier than going into the tunnel to make sure the tyres have been inflated and seated appropriately. Wheels have been then mounted into the take a look at bike by a Silverstone Sports activities Engineering Hub engineer to make sure consistency. 

Holding the bike in place was a set of stanchions. No corrections have been made for these since they have been the identical throughout all assessments. We’re within the distinction between wheels right here, not absolutely the values. 

Confidence

Our confidence margin for our outcomes is +/- 0.0009 CdA, or 0.32 watts at 30kph, 0.76 watts at 40kph, or 1.49 watts at 50kph.

This was calculated with a baseline take a look at firstly of the day and an end-of-day repeat with the identical setup after the tyres, cassette and rotors had been eliminated and refitted. 

Different knowledge we captured

We all know that aerodynamics is just one a part of the puzzle that mixes to create a wheelset’s general efficiency, so all through the day, we additionally captured some further knowledge. We did not seize inside width as a result of our calipers could not measure hooked rims precisely, so we’ll use quoted inside widths the place related. 

WeightExternal width DepthMeasured width of a 28mm tyreHooked or hooklessAnd lastly, worth! 

Extra particulars and disclaimers

Cyclingnews doesn’t declare that this knowledge is the ultimate phrase on the aerodynamic efficiency of the wheels featured, however quite a further stream of unbiased, unbiased testing and data for our readers. 

The outcomes are merely consultant of our day of testing. We hope that being clear about our methodology and our protocol permits readers to understand the information whereas additionally understanding the larger image. 

We perceive that producers could obtain completely different outcomes with completely different protocols, and that some wheels on this take a look at have been designed round completely different tyre fashions, completely different tyre widths, and generally along with a selected bike. The place we have now data to this finish, we’ll embrace it.

For simplicity, we’ll report particular person CdA knowledge because it comes out of the wind tunnel software program, however the place related, the graphs used present our error margin. 

When averaging the CdA knowledge, we have now weighted yaw angles in line with the 2018 analysis paper by Cannondale’s Nathan Barry. This calculates the probability of experiencing every yaw angle at given speeds in the actual world and applies an applicable weighting to every CdA measurement. In layman’s phrases, as you journey quicker, you are extra prone to expertise low yaw (wind head-on) than excessive yaw (crosswind), just by advantage of the velocity of your motion by means of the air. 

Weighting the yaw angles appropriately when averaging the CdA offers a extra correct real-world interpretation of which wheelset will truly make you quicker. 

Utilizing these averages, we have then calculated to resolve for energy (watts) on the examined speeds. These calculations use a continuing air density of 1.2kg/m³, and don’t consider further losses corresponding to drivetrain friction or rolling resistance. 

Cyclingnews additionally understands that there’s extra to a wheelset’s efficiency than aerodynamics. Weight, dealing with and stability are key for trip high quality, whereas serviceability, tyre compatibility and retention, and the way straightforward they’re to get the tyres on and off are additionally essential. This context shouldn’t be ignored when viewing the outcomes beneath. 

Current on the day

Me – Josh Croxton: Overseeing the take a look at, serving to with wheelset preparation, guaranteeing tyres have been seated and pressured appropriately previous to testing, serving to with wheelset swapsTom Wieckowski: In control of wheelset preparation and extra knowledge captureWill Jones: Chief images officer, chargeable for all the wonderful images you see right here, and serving to with wheelset preparationSam Gupta: Chief videography officer, chargeable for social media video creation and serving to with wheelset preparationBen Meir (Reap Bikes): Supplier of the take a look at bike, assisted Silverstone’s engineers with wheelset swapsThe workforce from Silverstone Sports activities Engineering Hub: Operating the wind tunnel to make sure dependable outcomes, and answerable for swapping wheels to make sure truthful protocols

Outcomes

And with all that carried out, let’s get into the enjoyable stuff, the outcomes!

Given we have now the CdA of the bike alone, quite than a motorcycle with a rider on it, the calculated wattage numbers are small. To elucidate: An approximate CdA for a highway bicycle owner is round 0.3, whereas the CdA values listed below are between 0.09 and 0.1, and the approximate wattage to trip at 40km/h right here works out at between 65 and 80 watts. That is unrealistic, however it’s nonetheless legitimate for evaluating one towards one other. A few of the graphs beneath will quote this knowledge, however I’ve additionally calculated the watts saved vs the baseline wheelset. 

Most of this part will probably be graphs and tables, however beneath, we’ll dive into every wheelset to offer particular person findings. 

Maintain onto your hats!

Beginning with some uncooked knowledge, the above graph exhibits the CdA for every wheelset at every yaw angle, examined at 30kph. Discover how some wheels get quicker at greater yaw angles as they use the wind to sail. 

Subsequent up, the identical CdA knowledge for every wheelset at every yaw angle, however when examined at 40kph.

Right here, most wheels are inside a detailed vary at zero yaw, however whereas the Black Inc 48/58 will get progressively slower because the wind comes from the facet, the remainder are inclined to sail at 10 levels or extra. The Syncros wheels are quickest at 5 and 10 levels, however the Scope wheels are tremendous quick at 15 levels. 

Subsequent up, the identical knowledge once more, however examined at 50kph.

As soon as once more, these Syncros wheels are fast at 5 to 10 levels, however the Scope wheels are marginally faster at 0 yaw, and quicker than anybody at 15.

Curiously, the Roval Rapide CLX II carried out worst at this velocity at decrease yaw, however at 15, it sailed properly. 

Up to now we have teased out a couple of issues, however with so many intersecting traces, it is tough to tug out any actual tendencies, so subsequent up, I’ve averaged the CdA outcomes and labored out the watts required to pedal on the three given speeds (30, 40 and 50kph). 

Analysing these three charts, you’ll be able to see that throughout all speeds, the Scope Artech 6.A and the Syncros Capital SL Aero did very properly. The Enve 6.7 wasn’t far behind, and the Imaginative and prescient Metron 60 SL was up there too. Additionally a shout out to the budget-friendly Scribe Core SuperLight 60, which at £999 for a pair, punched properly above its worth level. 

There is a little bit of a pattern to focus on right here too, in that the deeper wheels unsurprisingly fared higher than the shallower wheels. There have been some outliers although, such because the ~60mm deep Princeton Carbonworks Wake 6560 Evo and the Campagnolo Bora WTO 60, which each landed mid-table outcomes, and the Enve SES 4.5 which beat them each. 

Black Inc could also be disheartened to see its 48/58 wheelset carried out poorly however will probably be buoyed by the truth that its newer aero wheelset, the Sixty Two, was within the prime half constantly, aided within the huge image by their comparatively low weight too. 

After all, do not forget there’s an error margin to account for, which might shuffle most wheelsets up or down a couple of locations, and keep in mind that the three X-Axes right here begin above zero, so the outcomes seem extra pronounced. 

Watts saved vs baseline

I believe that is the clearest graph of all of them. It exhibits the watts saved towards our baseline wheelset for every of the three speeds. I’ve ordered by 40kph. Observe how the Princeton wheels work higher on the greater velocity, and the Reserve wheels carry out higher on the decrease velocity.

From our knowledge, we will conclude with confidence that at professional peloton speeds of 50kph, the Scope Artech 6.A wheels are no less than 3.42 watts quicker than the Roval Rapide CLX II.

At extra novice racing speeds of 40kph, we will conclude that you just stand to save lots of no less than 8.99 watts when upgrading from an entry-level wheelset to the quickest.

We will additionally say that at a extra on a regular basis velocity of 30kph, the budget-friendly Scribe Core 60 wheels will prevent on the very least 3.51 watts, or 1 minute 43 seconds over a 40km time trial driving at 250 watts.

Error margins work each methods although, so taking it the opposite method, if we calculate the utmost doable saving (in line with our statistical error) between the baseline Fulcrum wheels and the Syncros Capital SL Aero at 50kph, you stand to save lots of a major 20.63 watts.

I do know not too many individuals will probably be upgrading from a baseline to a wheelset as premium as these Syncros wheels although, so a extra life like improve to the Scribe Core 60 can prevent as a lot as 18.63 watts.

At 30kph, a velocity most of us will be capable to trip, you stand to save lots of as many as 5.63 watts switching between the baseline wheels and the Scopes.

Aero vs weight

The accepted rule with wheels is that usually, the deeper they’re, the extra aerodynamic they’re, however with further materials comes further weight, so the commerce off often goes one thing like “do I need to prioritise aero for flatland velocity, or save weight and be quicker when climbing?”

Whereas the above rule continues to be a good generalisation, our take a look at discovered the other correlation. The Scope Artech 6.A wheels, which have been the quickest at 30 and 40kph, have been additionally the lightest on our take a look at at 1280g. The Syncros Capital SL 50 – quickest at 50kph – have been the second lightest at 1311g!

Now, there’s one other huge half to this equation which you will have already discovered, and that’s worth.

Aero vs worth

These two wheelsets – the Syncros and the Scope – additionally occur to be the costliest on take a look at, which suggests the extra you pay, the higher efficiency you’ll be able to count on to get.

Throughout the 18 wheelsets, our take a look at discovered a slight correlation between worth and efficiency – no surprises there – nevertheless it’s not fully clear-cut. In response to our outcomes, you are not assured velocity in the event you spend extra, and you’ll positively get velocity with out spending heaps. 

Particular person outcomes

Now it is time to dig into every wheelset’s efficiency at a person degree. Right here I’ll listing the entire knowledge we captured, alongside a graph of the CdA vs yaw for every of the three speeds. 

I may even add some context round every wheel the place I’ve it, corresponding to if the wheel was designed round a selected tyre width, along with a selected bike, or developed by the model utilizing completely different testing protocols. 

What’s extra, every of the manufacturers within the take a look at has been given a possibility to analyse the information and supply a remark previous to publishing. Not each model has chosen to, and that is fantastic. Others have been extraordinarily clear and forthcoming in explaining their designs and motivations. The place a remark has been obtained, it is going to be included.

Fulcrum Racing 5

Beginning with our baseline wheelset, the 24mm deep, alloy-rim Fulcrum Racing 5 DB. These are a reasonably on a regular basis entry-level mannequin. 

They will by no means compete with the deeper-section aero wheels, however given they’re priced at a 3rd of the value of the most cost effective set right here, and round a tenth of the value of the costliest, that is hardly a shock. 

To our thoughts, they seem to be a fairly good illustration of the wheels you are prone to get in your entry- to mid-level finances highway bike, so will hopefully offer you a really feel for what number of watts it can save you when upgrading your personal bike. 

They do function a fairly trendy ‘U’ formed forefront, however their 24mm depth does little to make use of the wind to its benefit. At 20mm inside, they’re the narrowest on take a look at, however you may discover wheels as slim as 17mm in the event you store at this pricepoint. They weighed in on our scales at just a little over 1.7kg, which once more, is the heaviest on take a look at. 

Black Inc 48/58

The Black Inc 48/58 is the primary of two Black Inc wheels we examined right here. They’re specced on the Issue Ostro VAM which got here out very properly in our latest highway bike wind tunnel take a look at. The truth that they’ve come out among the many slowest right here exhibits simply how aerodynamic that body have to be. The deeper Black Inc Sixty Two wheels, detailed beneath, are newer and deeper, and Issue needs to be buoyed by the truth that they’re quicker. 

The 48/58 wheels are, because the identify suggests, 48mm deep on the entrance and 58mm deep on the rear. They’re fairly light-weight at 1366 grams, thanks partially to the carbon spokes and the light-weight hub, however they don’t seem to be fairly market-leading for a wheelset of this depth. 

They function a 23mm inside bead with a ‘mini-bead hook’ that’s genuinely minuscule, and the 28mm Schwalbe tyre blew as much as just a little over 29mm by our calipers. 

Notably, within the graph above, you’ll be able to see how they struggled to sail on the greater yaws at 30 and 40kph, truly getting slower at greater yaws till you get to 50kph. In the actual world, this may doubtless imply it is advisable to work tougher in windier circumstances at these speeds. 

Shimano Dura Ace C50

With their 50mm depth, 28mm exterior width and 21mm inside width, the Shimano Dura-Ace C50 is the wheelset of selection for a lot of WorldTour groups. They’re the wheelset that Mathieu Van der Poel used to win the 2024 Paris Roubaix, for instance, in order that they have some fairly critical victories below their belt, regardless of not touchdown such an important end result on this take a look at. 

On our scales, they got here in at 1492g, which is not portly however is definitely overwhelmed by different 50mm choices right here. Maybe surprisingly, our tyres measured up barely wider on the rear than on the entrance, regardless of no apparent distinction between the 2 rim shapes.

Roval Rapide CLX II

The Roval Rapide CLX II wheels are one other common WorldTour winner, partially as a result of Specialised’s sponsorship of Soudal-QuickStep and RedBull Bora-Hansgrohe within the males’s peloton and SD Worx-Protime within the ladies’s. These wheels claimed victory on the Tour de France Femmes in 2023 and have numerous victories beneath Remco Evenepoel over latest years. It is value noting although that earlier in 2024, the model launched the restricted version Rapide CLX II Workforce wheels, which included a really cool-looking silver hub and tipped the scales at 130g much less. Given these can be found in a restricted quantity solely, we selected to check the usual wheels as a substitute. 

The variations between the entrance and the rear wheels are fairly stark. To begin with, the entrance is 51mm deep, whereas the rear is 60mm, after which regardless of each entrance and rear having a 21mm inside width, the entrance is a large 35mm large up entrance, and the rear is relatively slim at 30.7mm. 

As we perceive it, the wheels have been initially designed across the Specialised Turbo Cotton tyre. The model guarantees “the identical aerodynamic efficiency throughout numerous tyre sizes,” and recommends 28 or 30mm. They have been additionally designed along with the Specialised Tarmac, whereas we have examined with a Reap Vekta bike right here. 

Regardless, I am glad to simply accept that the end result right here is considerably stunning. In our earlier wheel take a look at in 2022, the Rapide CLX got here out quicker than the Zipp 404 and marginally slower than the Imaginative and prescient Metron 60 SL, whereas right here it is slower than each. What’s extra, in testing revealed by Hunt, the Rapide CLX II got here out quicker than the Sub 50 UD Carbon Spoke, whereas the Hunt wheel has come out barely quicker right here. 

There is a margin of error to account for right here although, and if we account for that, the Rapides may simply have completed within the prime half of the desk in any respect speeds.

As promised, we allowed every model to touch upon our outcomes, and Specialised mentioned the next: 

“We admire Cyclingnews’ dedication to unbiased data-based reporting. Sadly, these outcomes do not align with earlier third-party testing, our personal inside testing, [and] different manufacturers’ testing. The outcomes should not correct to what we all know is true for our product and lots of the others on this take a look at. We might be very hesitant for any rider to make a real-world determination based mostly on the result of this take a look at. We have provided to have an open dialogue with Cyclingnews to study from them and to share our learnings from 1000’s of days of testing in a number of tunnels around the globe.”

Specialised is not the primary model to supply an open dialogue in relation to our lab assessments, and as I’ve carried out with all others to date, I’ll fortunately settle for and attempt to study methods we will enhance these assessments for our readers. 

Zipp 404 Firecrest

The Zipp 404 Firecrest wheels are hookless, with a 23mm inside rim width and a 58mm depth.

They don’t seem to be the top-end wheels in Zipp’s all-rounder 404 vary, that accolade goes to the 454 NSW with their sawtooth profile. Sadly, SRAM could not get these wheels to us in time. 

The 404 Firecrests may not get that sawtooth profile, however they do get a dimpled floor throughout the face of the rim, which Zipp says helps handle airflow across the rim and contributes to a quicker, extra steady wheel. We’ve not examined stability right here, however having ridden them, I’ve no purpose to argue this declare. 

In our take a look at, they could have landed within the backside half, however they’re amongst a cluster of wheels with an identical end result, so with our confidence margin taken into consideration, they’ll lay declare to as excessive as sixth place. 

“This protocol seems stable,” complemented Zipp’s Class Supervisor, David Morse.

He defined that by testing the wheels in a motorcycle, we had captured “the interactions between the wheel, the bike, and the parts, which is usually a vital issue,” including that our determination to check with out a rider is “good for repeatability however leaves off some vital context.” 

“For the needs of this take a look at, it’s in all probability the best selection to depart the rider off because the take a look at goals to indicate actually small variations.”

“Aero wheel design has converged over the previous 5 to 10 years and the variations have gotten much more marginal.”

Curiously, and reassuringly, having solely seen the uncooked knowledge, Morse requested that our wattage figures spotlight the error margin and that we use a weighted common yaw end result. Each of those I had already carried out earlier than his Eleventh-hour remark landed in my inbox. 

He additionally gave some perception into Zipp’s testing strategies, which can assist our future wheel assessments: “At Zipp, we usually take a look at large yaws first and work again to 0 from both sides. We’ve got seen this drives extra constant outcomes as a result of it forces a stall situation originally of the take a look at run.”

Extra particular to the 404 wheels, he drew reference to Zipp’s ‘Complete System Effectivity’ which is one other reminder that we should not overlook the larger image when contemplating these outcomes:

“We made a tradeoff between aerodynamics and CRR because of the wider tyre mattress, which is 23mm inside. A 28mm labelled tyre will measure wider on the 404 Firecrest than most different wheels examined, which can affect the aero efficiency in a barely unfavorable method, but additionally affect the rolling resistance positively. 

“Given the tight margins between lots of the wheels, this might result in vital adjustments within the rankings throughout wheel fashions. We might count on the 404 Firecrest to leap up within the rankings after contemplating the CRR advantages of a wider tyre mattress, even when it’s a 1 to 2W CRR profit at 30kph. This deliberate technique comes from Zipp’s Complete System Effectivity (TSE) design philosophy.”

Swiss Facet Hadron Final 500

There isn’t any doubting Swiss Facet’s aero credentials, and though the model makes the Hadron2 Final in a 62mm depth, the one ones we may get our palms on right here have been the 50mm deep model. They arrive with a comparatively slim inside rim width of 20mm, a quoted exterior width of 27mm (although 26.5 on our verniers). Regardless of this, they ballooned our tyres out to round 29mm.

At 50mm, they have been among the shallower choices on this take a look at, however fared fairly properly regardless, sitting amongst a cluster of comparable performers in any respect speeds. Swiss Facet says they’re designed round 25 and 28mm tyres. The chrome steel spokes are bladed, they usually include hidden nipples in addition to a flange that covers the spokes on the hub, which maybe contributed to the general efficiency. 

Princeton Carbonworks Wake 6560 Evolution

The Princeton Carbonworks wheels are a extremely revered premium wheel model. A lot in order that the Ineos Grenadiers have been glad to interrupt out of an current sponsorship settlement to make use of them. 

In response to the model’s CEO, Harrison Macris, the model’s purpose with these wheels was “to offer one of the best wheel for our professional peloton riders and the tyre they specify, and can solely change or replace our wheels after we know precisely what tyres they are going to be on.”

They function an uncommon wave profile. In response to the model’s web site, that is mentioned to “permit the steeper, high-tension spokes (drive facet rear spokes and disc facet entrance spokes) to hook up with a deeper rim part, thereby flattening these spoke angles.”

This, the model says, helps to steadiness spoke tensions, making a stiffer, extra uniform wheel.

They’re 1,453g for a pair on our scales, and given they do not want rim tape, will assist to save lots of a little bit of weight there too. They’ve a 21mm inside width, and blew our tyres out to 29.5 and 29mm respectively. 

Maybe most essential of all although, is that the Princeton Carbonworks Wake 6560 Evo wheels can be found in a rim brake guise – a rarity lately. 

Cadex 50 Extremely

The Cadex 50 Extremely wheels are, because the identify suggests, 50mm deep. Their get together trick is the ultra-deep carbon-bladed spokes. They lace Cadex’s personal RC-3 Aero hubs, with their ceramic bearings, into rims that boast a 22.4mm inside width and hookless beads. Our 28mm tyres have been inflated out to a constant 29mm entrance and rear. 

The wheels tipped the scales at 1413g, which though not the lightest, have been solely overwhelmed by costlier fashions.

In response to Large, in its personal competitor benchmark testing, the Cadex 50 Extremely wheels outperformed among the fashions which have overwhelmed it right here, and its engineers imagine that is because of their take a look at utilizing a pedalling dummy, versus the bike-only protocol we have used. Having delved into the model’s whitepaper, it is evident the model’s personal protocol went deeper than ours, as we would count on.

It included a take a look at with Cadex’s personal Aero tyre; a second take a look at with the Race, the GP5000 25, the S-Works Turbo 26, and a Vittoria Corsa 25c; a 3rd take a look at with these tyres when mounted right into a Large Propel Superior SL, after which a fourth take a look at with the Cadex Aero tyres when mounted on the Propel, a Specialised Tarmac SL7, a Canyon Aeroad CFR, and a Cervélo S5. Within the on-bike assessments, a pedalling dummy was used. 

Regardless of the variations, Large’s consultant was pleased with the outcomes of our take a look at, given it was up towards some deeper opponents. 

Campagnolo Bora WTO 60

The Bora WTO 60 aren’t Campagnolo’s top-tier wheel within the Bora vary. That accolade goes to the Bora Extremely WTO, which boasts fewer spokes, hidden nipples, ceramic bearings, weight reduction, and some different tips. Sadly, we could not get these in time, however these held their very own very properly. 

Regardless of their 60mm depth, they have been mid-table on the burden scales at 1491g, beating a handful of shallower fashions. Will – my esteemed colleague – thinks these are the best-looking of the bunch. The G3 spoke sample, which teams spokes into threes and doubles the drive-side spoke depend, definitely provides an aesthetic level of distinction, and Campagnolo says it helps to counteract the uneven drivetrain and disc braking forces. 

They’ve hooked beads, cut up by a 23mm rim mattress, and our 28mm tyres blew out to 30mm entrance and rear. 

You’ll be able to see within the graph above that they stalled a bit at 30kph, getting slower quite than quicker at 10 and 15 levels, however because the velocity grew, their efficiency did too. 

Black Inc 62

Black Inc is a subsidiary of Issue Bikes, a rising model out of Taiwan owned by Miami-born Rob Gitelis, who constructed his profession proudly owning factories and constructing bikes for manufacturers he now calls opponents, corresponding to Cervélo. His manufacturing unit is now completely used on Issue’s bikes and Black Inc’s parts, as he defined in our in-depth interview earlier this 12 months.  

The Black Inc 62 are the model’s deepest highway wheels (excluding discs and trispokes), and landed a stable sixth place on the scales at 1425g. They boast an inside width of 23mm, with a ‘mini hook’ bead. They’re beneficial with a 28mm tyre, and blew our Schwalbe Professional Ones out to 30.2mm each entrance and rear. They’re made with carbon fibre spokes and Black Inc’s personal light-weight hubs. 

To my thoughts, they’re among the best-looking of this bunch, although the massive white logos may put some individuals off. 

Just like the Campagnolo wheels above, they stalled considerably at 30kph, getting slower at greater yaw angles, however they got here into their very own at greater speeds. In a perfect world, we would take a look at every wheel at a better variety of yaw angles and extra speeds to seek out out the purpose at which the wheel begins to sail, however that is not massively essential for a broader comparative take a look at corresponding to this. 

Hunt Sub 50 Limitless UD Carbon Spoke

The Sub 50 Limitless is available in two guises, with chrome steel spokes or with lighter-weight UD carbon spokes. Our take a look at right here contains the latter, priced at £1,849.

Hunt’s transparency in its testing when launching these is to be applauded. It exhibits each the Roval Rapide and the Enve SES 4.5 as being quicker however leans on the low weight of the Sub 50 and positions it as a superb steadiness of weight and aero. In our Hunt Sub 50 evaluation, our reviewer Josh Ross was very impressed, giving them 4.5 out of 5 stars. 

Hunt additionally affords a lifetime ‘H_Care’ crash alternative guarantee on this wheelset, freed from cost. So in the event you’re the unique proprietor and also you write them off in a crash, you may get a alternative set for free of charge. It is not the one model to supply such a factor, however amongst all this speak of watts and grams saved, this can be a tangible profit, bringing peace of thoughts to most of us for whom a brand new aero wheelset is an actual funding. 

Notably, in contrast to the Campag and Black Inc 62 wheels above, the Hunts did properly in any respect speeds, catching the wind at greater yaw to cut back drag even at decrease speeds. 

Given the Sub 50 are among the many shallower on take a look at, Hunt’s proprietor, Tom Marchment, was pleased with their efficiency:

“We’re very happy with these outcomes exhibiting us within the prime three throughout all speeds for aerodynamic acquire per mm depth – outperforming all different wheelsets of an identical depth. This exhibits that our superior aerodynamic shapes are efficient in creating positive aspects throughout the velocity vary with out having to simply accept the compromises historically related to very deep-section wheels.”

Marchment then went on to clarify Hunt’s personal protocols: 

“We take a look at additional, to the broader yaw angles of the Mavic WAD. The advantages proven right here on the Sub 50 Limitless and, for instance, the Roval Rapide CLX II proceed into wider crosswinds than measured on this take a look at offering decrease drag, extra stability and better predictability than extra conventional, narrower V shapes.” 

Parcours Strade

Parcours is a British model with a fame for providing good wheelsets at a superb worth. The mannequin examined right here have been priced at simply £1,099.00, although you’ll be able to improve to ceramic bearings for a £300 uplift. Along with the comparatively low worth level, the Strade additionally comes in as one of many shallower choices in our take a look at, so punches above its weight fairly properly. 

If you take the error margin into consideration, these wheels can lay declare to 4th place at 30 and 40kph, and third – a podium end – at 50kph. Spectacular stuff. 

Parcours founder, Dov Tate, is an Oxford-educated engineer with a historical past in aerospace, and is constructing one thing of a fame for pushing the boundary of biking aero testing and understanding. His analysis into yaw angle weighting and time trial tyre aero testing are two such examples. Of all of the manufacturers we contacted, Tate was most eager to know our testing methodology and subsequent calculations.

He provided a selected remark, which I’ve pasted in verbatim beneath: 

“We’re thrilled to see how properly the Strade wheelset carried out in such a complete take a look at and it was unbelievable to see the outcomes when up towards some deeper competitors. Moreover, we have been additionally happy to know how the leads to our most commonly-recorded real-world wind circumstances actually make the wheels stand out towards some top-class competitors.”

Reserve 52/63

After we examined wheels in 2022, Reserve was nonetheless a comparatively unknown model. It sponsored the ladies’s Jumbo Visma workforce, however the males’s workforce have been nonetheless racing on Shimano. Its 50/65 wheels got here final in our take a look at – not by a lot, however final nonetheless – and the response I obtained from my contact at PON Holdings – the father or mother firm behind Reserve, Cervélo, Santa Cruz and others – was one thing alongside the traces of “we’ll enhance.”

And boy have they. Since that take a look at, Reserve has doubled its sponsorship to the lads’s workforce – now often known as Visma-Lease A Bike – and its wheels have come on leaps and bounds, providing wider profiles, shaping tyres properly (wider than every other right here) and profitable all three of the lads’s grand excursions within the 2023 season. 

At 30kph, they examined fifth quickest, and with our error margin taken into consideration, can lay declare to a win. With that mentioned, although, at greater speeds they fell down the pecking order barely.

Enve SES 4.5

Regardless of their identify, the depth of the Enve SES 4.5 is not 45mm, however 50mm on the entrance and 56mm on the rear. That places them simply on the shallower finish of our take a look at. They’re additionally the wheels with the widest inside width on our take a look at, at 25mm, with an exterior of 32.55mm on the widest level. They ballooned our 28mm Schwalbe Professional One tyre out to 30.1mm.

Enve says they’re aero-optimised for tyres between 27 and 28mm large (as labelled). The model makes its personal tyres, so presumably there could be a slight aero profit to utilizing these, however as talked about a couple of instances already, we wished to standardise to keep away from providing any wheel an unfair benefit. 

Curiously, perhaps as a result of that wider width, the SES 4.5 weighed barely extra on our scales than the deeper Enve SES 6.7, albeit at a distinction of simply 11 grams.

Scribe Core SuperLight 60

Maybe one of the best worth success story of this take a look at comes from the Belfast, Northern Eire-based Scribe, with its sub-£1000 Core SuperLight 60 wheelset. 

The model says its purpose is “to supply clients the best-specced wheels doable; for the cash and the extent of expertise.”

Weighing in at 1442 grams, they don’t seem to be absolutely the lightest on this take a look at, however in comparison with the opposite 60mm wheels, they’re fairly good. They’re overwhelmed by the hyper-pricey Scope and Syncros choices, however they’re 50g lighter than each the Campagnolo Bora WTO and Enve SES 6.7 wheels, and a powerful 185g lower than Imaginative and prescient’s Metron 60 SL. 

In any respect speeds, they’ll lay declare to a podium end as soon as our error margin is accounted for, and may even declare prime spot at 40 or 50kph. That is despite a comparatively slim (by at present’s requirements) 21mm inside width, which contributed to tyre widths of 28.7 and 28.9mm entrance and rear respectively. 

They’re one other model to supply a lifetime crash alternative scheme, in addition to a three-year guarantee. On prime of this, you’ll be able to commerce them in through the model’s Re Gen scheme. 

Understandably, the model was pleased with the outcomes. 

“We have been creating the SL vary to push the boundaries of aerodynamics (and rolling resistance) for a very long time, and it is nice to go head-to-head with the most important gamers on the market. We additionally hand-build all of our wheels at our operations in N. Eire to ensure we have now full management of QC.”

Imaginative and prescient Metron 60 SL

One other with fairly a excessive WorldTour presence, the Imaginative and prescient Metron 60 SL is, by the model’s personal admission, an older design now, and when provided a remark, merely acknowledged they have been “greater than happy contemplating the typical value of the opposite wheelsets.”

That outdated design features a comparatively slim (by at present’s requirements) 21mm inside width, and a 28.9mm exterior by our verniers. They’re designed round a 28mm tyre, with a hooked bead, chrome steel aero-bladed spokes and metal bearings (quite than the occasionally-specced ceramic)

In our take a look at, they weighed in at 1628g with out valves or tape, however with the Shimano freehub. This was a little bit of a shock given after we weighed them for our final take a look at, they have been 1460g, they usually have been 1580g with valves and tape after we reviewed them. We have since weighed them once more on a distinct scale with the identical end result, so we’re assured this quantity is correct for the wheelset examined on the day.

Regardless, the quantity you’ll be able to belief is the CdA worth, which like our Metron 60 SL evaluation concluded, exhibits an honest efficiency, together with a 2nd place at 30kph, 4th place at 40kph and fifth place at 50kph. As soon as the error margin is accounted for, Imaginative and prescient can technically declare victory throughout the board, saving you as many as 11 watts at 40kph towards our baseline wheels. 

ENVE SES 6.7

Into the highest three, when ranked by common CdA throughout all speeds, we have now the Enve SES 6.7, which can prevent a powerful 16.79 watts towards the baseline at professional racing speeds of 50kph. They’re the wheels that Tadej Pogačar used all through his dominant 2024 season and have been in truth chosen by UAE Workforce Emirates workers off the again of a LOT of comparative aero testing by the workforce. I for one would like to see that knowledge. 

They function a contemporary form, with an inside width of 23mm and an exterior of 30.4 up entrance, and 29.4 on the rear by our measurement. That blew the tyres out to 29.5mm in each circumstances and created a easy transition from tyre to rim. They did a superb job of crusing at greater yaw, however provided an honest aero efficiency throughout all yaw angles in any respect speeds, making them an obvious good all-rounder. 

They’re barely let down by their weight, although. Given their £3300 worth, you would be forgiven for anticipating extra (properly, much less) right here. 

Syncros Capital SL Aero

The Syncros Capital SL Aero are the costliest wheels on this take a look at, at a fairly wild £4,200, however what’s even wilder is their design, which includes a one-piece carbon building that features 16 carbon spokes per wheel. It additionally boasts a hookless rim bead and 23mm inside width that, in our take a look at, blew the tyres out to 29 and 30mm respectively. 

Syncros says the carbon spokes are 35% stronger than metal spokes, whereas including torsional stiffness too. 

Impressively, regardless of their 60mm depth, they tipped the scales at 1311g and given they do not want rim tape to work tubeless, they save a couple of grams there too.

Notably, they’re designed round Schwalbe’s 28mm Professional One Aero tyre, which whereas much like the Professional One TLE we used, options notable variations together with various profiles entrance and rear, and claims a 20% drag discount in comparison with the Professional One TT.

Scope Artech 6.A

And at last, the de facto winner (though I have to remind you of the error margin), the Scope Artech 6.A. Curiously, the ‘.A’ a part of the identify means that is truly the all-road model of this wheel, quite than the pure road-going model. Meaning it is barely wider, with a 25mm inside quite than 23, and marginally heavier by Scope’s claims at 1319g as a substitute of 1244g. On our scales, they got here out at 1280g. 

They’re 60mm deep, and have what Scope calls ‘Aeroscales’. To you and me, that successfully means a fish-scale model end throughout the floor of the rim. The declare is these “generate velocity streaks travelling at completely different velocity over our rim floor. This has a stabilizing impact on the airflow and reduces drag.”

Additionally they boast ‘Algorithm Enhanced Aerodynamics,’ and extra tangibly, a light-weight 3D-printed hub created from Scalmalloy (a mix of aluminum, magnesium, and scandium), which boasts a Diamond Ratchet SL freehub inside, which is created from titanium and “completed with a diamond-like carbon coating.”

All in all, the Scope wheels are full of modern tech, they appear quick and really feel unimaginable. By our knowledge, they’re the each the quickest and lightest on take a look at, saving as a lot as 20.6 watts and 435g over our benchmark. 

The near-£3,500 price ticket displays that, however in the event you’re in search of a money-no-object improve, you are in the best place. 

Conclusions

Which wheelset is quickest?

There isn’t any clear-cut reply right here, as a result of in testing at a number of speeds, we have now landed on a number of winners, and the highest few wheels are shut sufficient that they are inside our error margin. 

If we common out the CdA throughout all three speeds, the wheelset that examined quickest is the Scope Artech 6.A. Given they have been additionally the lightest wheels on our take a look at, it is secure to say they’re an important all-rounder. 

With our error margin accounted for, the Scope, Imaginative and prescient, Syncros and Enve SES 6.7 can all lay declare to the highest spot at 30kph. At 40kph, any of those self same wheels, in addition to the budget-friendly Scribe Core 60 can lay declare to the highest spot. And at 50kph, those self same 5 wheelsets plus the Princeton Carbonworks Wake 6560 Evo can declare a victory. The outcomes have been actually that shut! And that is an important factor to recollect.

A key takeaway

Given how shut the outcomes are, until you are chasing each final watt of aero acquire, you shouldn’t low cost the opposite elements that make up a wheel’s efficiency. Issues like steering stability, which we’ve not measured right here, are a key issue to your velocity – in the event you’re wobbling in crosswinds otherwise you’re lacking a nook’s apex, you are shedding a few of that ‘free’ velocity you acquire. 

Value is a giant issue too. You probably have deep pockets, then the likes of the Scope or Syncros wheels will, by our knowledge, web you some real-world go-faster positive aspects, however in the event you’re on a finances, you may need to contemplate some secondary advantages, corresponding to guarantee, aftercare and ease of serviceability. 

Manufacturers like Enve, Zipp, Roval and Hunt supply a very good guarantee service. In the event you crash your Roval wheels within the first two years of possession, for instance, Specialised will change them without cost. That is definitely one thing to remember in the event you’re racing.

All in all, you should not low cost our knowledge, however it is best to definitely be conscious of the larger image in the event you’re utilizing it to make a purchase order.

The place to spend your cash first?

Up to now, the ‘CN Labs’ assessments, as we’re calling them, have examined helmets, bikes, tyres and wheels, and what we will deduce from the assessments we have carried out to date, is that wheels do not supply excellent worth for cash if we have a look at pure aero positive aspects alone. 

With bikes, a high-end mannequin will prevent as many as 40 watts over a really entry-level bike on the similar velocity, however the worth is within the five-figure mark for that huge a saving, so that you’re taking a look at round £250 per watt. Even the most cost effective bike on that take a look at was £8000, and saved 35 watts, that means you’d pay round £230 per watt. 

Wheels do not supply fairly that dangerous a price, nevertheless it’s not precisely nice. To improve to the Scope wheels, you may be spending over £3000 for round a 10-watt acquire at 40kph, so £300 per watt, however in the event you contemplate the results of the budget-friendly Scribe wheels, they netted a 9-watt saving for £1000, which is just a little over £111 per watt. 

In the meantime, with helmets, it can save you someplace within the area of 12 watts at 40kph, at a tough value of £250. That is just a little over £20 per watt.

We might be spending our cash on tyres first although. Tyres are less expensive, at round £160 for a very premium pair, and supply a saving of round 22 watts between a quick all-rounder and a winter mannequin. That is just a little higher than £8 per watt. 

What ought to we take a look at subsequent? Be happy to achieve out and tell us. 

Thank yous

Subscribers: With out your ongoing dedication to us, these assessments wouldn’t be doable.

Silverstone Sports activities Engineering Hub: For his or her steering on protocol, operating the wind tunnel for us, and for guaranteeing correct protocols all through an extended day of testing.

Every of the manufacturers featured: For the mortgage of the wheels proven.

Ben Meir, Reap Bikes: For the mortgage of the Vekta bike and aiding on the day.

Schwalbe: For the mortgage of the Professional One TLE tyres.

Tom, Will and Sam: For serving to to swap over 40 tyres, 40 rotors and 20 cassettes in a day.

In the event you subscribe to Cyclingnews, it is best to join our new subscriber-only e-newsletter. From unique interviews and tech galleries to race evaluation and in-depth options, the Musette means you may by no means miss out on member-exclusive content material. Join now

–