Bucky Brooks was one of many first within the NFL scouting neighborhood to turn into an enormous believer in C.J. Stroud. Brooks, a former NFL participant who spent virtually a decade within the league as a scout, first acquired a way of simply how particular the Houston Texans phenom was when he coached Stroud earlier than his senior yr of highschool at The Opening, Nike’s gathering of prime prospects, in 2019.
When Brooks sizes up what is predicted to be a good higher quarterback crop than final yr’s draft class, he thinks Washington star Michael Penix Jr. is the C.J. Stroud of the 2024 group.
“To me, he was eerily just like C.J.’s coming-out celebration versus Georgia,” Brooks stated of Penix’s efficiency within the School Soccer Playoff semifinal towards Texas. “It was like, ‘Let me present you guys that I can transfer.’ When Penix took off on some quarterback energy, that jogged my memory of what I assumed he had at Indiana.
“He’s the one who performs it in a conventional sense, like the standard quarterback that they’ve at all times needed. Offers from the pocket. Fast launch. Beats individuals along with your thoughts and your arm versus your athleticism. He does that and has vital tape that exhibits that.”
Penix put up staggering numbers in main Washington to the nationwide title recreation after an undefeated common season.
The 23-year-old completed second within the Heisman Trophy race, throwing for 4,903 yards to guide the nation in passing for the second yr in a row. He had 67 touchdowns to 19 interceptions and accomplished 65 % of his passes in two years at Washington, doing it in an offensive scheme that thrived on downfield throws and vertical photographs.
He left rival coaches raving about what they noticed each in-person and on movie, versus some faculty QBs who put up gaudy stats with numerous dinking and dunking.
“I don’t know if I’ve seen that many coaches rave a couple of participant like that,” Brooks stated. “What these coaches stated backed up how I felt. I’m watching him towards Texas, and he’s carving them up. Then, I checked out Oregon within the Pac-12 Championship Sport, and he’s carving them up. These coaches speaking about how when you don’t change the look, he’s completely going to cube them up. All of the Cowl 3 beaters and all the different stuff that’s of their package deal, to me, that’s next-level stuff. And I do know for a reality with Drake Maye and a number of the different guys, they don’t have that of their bag.”
Michael Penix Jr. led Washington to a Pac-12 title win over Oregon in December. (Kirby Lee / USA At present)
Dane Brugler, The Athletic’s NFL Draft analyst, has known as Penix probably the most polarizing QB prospect in a draft class that features projected first-round picks like Maye, Caleb Williams, J.J. McCarthy and Jayden Daniels.
A few of that stems from Penix’s medical historical past, together with 4 season-ending accidents whereas at Indiana. A supply near Penix instructed The Athletic that on Monday the QB met together with his physician, who stated “his medicals are going to clear.”
There’s little doubt that Penix’s conferences with group docs and their evaluations shall be essential. However regardless, scouts will even be divided by his talent set.
“He operates a very aggressive offense,” Brugler stated. “At Washington, he knew he had actually good receivers, and to his credit score, he was trusting these guys to go make a play. A variety of these occasions, although, these guys had been bailing him out. He’s prepared to assault each small inch of the sphere and to throw into small home windows, however once you examine the tape, he was additionally inconsistent. His anticipation over the center of the sphere will not be a power of his.
“Within the Texas recreation, when he was dealing with extra of a vanilla protection, the entire recreation it felt like he knew precisely what he was doing. However then within the championship recreation towards Michigan, when he was dealing with the closest factor to an NFL protection that he’s confronted, he appeared uncertain of himself and was feeling the frenzy the second the ball was snapped. He missed a number of open reads due to that.”
Brugler stated that one scout lately instructed him Penix had a third-round grade and wouldn’t be drafted by his group. One other stated Penix can be a top-50 choose.
GO DEEPER
2024 NFL Mock Draft: Two rounds, 64 picks and 4 QBs within the prime 20
In 2020, Penix led Indiana to its greatest soccer season in 53 years.
The Hoosiers completed No. 12. He was named group MVP, even after a torn ACL ended his yr in Sport 6 of an eight-game slate shortened by COVID-19. However within the following yr, Penix suffered one other season-ending harm, a dislocated joint in his throwing shoulder in Indiana’s fifth recreation. The Hoosiers went 2-10.
Penix had been scuffling with the load of uncertainty that had come from his knee restoration earlier than the 2021 season started. He was extraordinarily candid with The Athletic and later with Pac-12 Community about what he had been feeling again at Indiana.
“It’s arduous,” a teary-eyed Penix stated final April. “I used to be scared to play, however I nonetheless tried to. It was only a lot. In my head, I stated if I’d gotten harm once more, I used to be gonna stop soccer.”
He talked about leaning on his household and his family members to persevere, including, “I simply love the sport a lot now.”
“I didn’t need to give it up,” he stated, “however clearly going by means of what I used to be going by means of, it was arduous. However I couldn’t surrender as a result of I’ve so many individuals relying on me and looking out as much as me. So, if I can play, I used to be gonna play. Except the physician stated I couldn’t.”
After my story was revealed final month, there was some chatter about how some NFL of us may view Penix’s phrases within the draft course of. Some groups may use his phrases towards him, and there could be questions on how the QB would deal with one other harm.
“He’ll get requested about it on the mix and it’ll turn into a much bigger story than perhaps it must be,” Brooks stated. “I’d, as a scout, admire his vulnerability. The one factor that I believe can maintain him down is the harm issue.”
Michael Penix Jr. threw for 4,197 yards in 4 injury-shortened years at Indiana. (Marc Lebryk / USA At present)
Daniel Jeremiah, one other former NFL scout who analyzes the draft for NFL Community, stated whereas which may give some NFL groups pause, in the end it can come all the way down to what medical individuals inform franchises after they verify Penix out.
“It’s gonna be one hundred pc what the docs say,” Jeremiah stated. “I don’t assume groups shall be apprehensive that he may hold it up as a result of he doesn’t need to rehab an ACL. I believe groups will wait till their medical individuals inform them if he can come again from a 3rd ACL.”
A number of the individuals The Athletic spoke to about Penix considered his perspective as way more of a constructive than a possible unfavorable because it pertains to his transition to the NFL and the way groups ought to view him being so clear about what had been going by means of his thoughts — and what that exhibits about his character.
“You may have two GMs and two organizations who will see this very otherwise,” stated former NFL quarterback Brock Huard, who has coated Penix as a TV analyst. “There shall be some that shall be turned off by that and that can use the medicals as the explanation for that, and there shall be others that shall be completely grateful for that grit and that have.
“You don’t perceive how a lot is thrown on these prime guys, and the way all of these expectations and that stress destroys them. Properly, Penix has been there and he’s confronted all of that and been on the opposite aspect. You’ve this full spectrum and gamut. What number of guys have that, from being completely damaged and scared, beat up — actually, figuratively, emotionally — after which from that different aspect of it? What number of have dealt with unbelievable stress and success of the goal getting greater and greater and working the entire present? I can’t think about there’s very most of the final 100 quarterback prospects taken which have had that full-boat spectrum.”
GO DEEPER
Michael Penix Jr.’s journey is not solely about soccer — it is overcoming worry
The hit price of first-round quarterbacks that reside as much as NFL groups’ expectations is stunningly low.
Should you begin with QBs drafted between 2000-20, it nets out to about one in three figuring out for these franchises. In 2021, there have been 5 QBs taken within the prime 15 picks: Trevor Lawrence, Zach Wilson, Trey Lance, Justin Fields and Mac Jones. It’s nonetheless early, nevertheless it’s a stretch to assume two of them will show to be franchise QBs.
Jeremiah has extensively studied why prime quarterbacks don’t reside as much as their hype within the NFL. He pointed to his former boss in Baltimore, Ozzie Newsome, at all times asking prospects to provide an instance of adversity they’ve handled.
“The No. 1 motive that high-pick quarterbacks don’t work out is failure to take care of adversity,” Jeremiah stated. “Earlier than they get drafted, these guys most likely haven’t had a lot adversity. They’re often the most effective child round, and now much more so as a result of all the greatest excessive faculties determine these youngsters and convey them in, so that you don’t have a lot of them enjoying with inferior youngsters round them.
“Then, they go to top-notch packages they usually play with superior expertise round them. However then they go to the NFL, which is the last word stage enjoying area. You’re gonna have adversity.”
Michigan held Michael Penix Jr. and Washington to 13 factors within the nationwide title recreation. (Thomas Shea / USA At present)
In 2013, the Buffalo Payments drafted EJ Manuel with the sixteenth choose. He was large and clever and had spectacular bodily instruments. He began 10 video games as a rookie and performed fairly nicely, however he had a collection of accidents that derailed his professional profession earlier than he might get any momentum.
“You begin questioning, how do individuals view you now?” Manuel stated. “Some individuals may assume you’re comfortable. You may see chirps and tweets and stuff like, ‘Aw, glass knees!’ I used to be like, ‘I’m simply enjoying soccer. Everyone will get harm sooner or later.’”
Manuel, now an ACC Community analyst, gives a superb window into what Penix has confronted and overcome and the way it could possibly be an enormous profit for his NFL profession.
“It’s important to construct that psychological callus to essentially take care of the issues on the sphere, which is tough,” Manuel stated. “It’s important to discover ways to be a professional; it’s a must to discover ways to discuss to your offensive line in regards to the belongings you’re anticipating and the appears to be like that you simply need to see, but in addition simply the off-the-field stuff. We’re all human.
“When he will get to the NFL, there gained’t be any scenario that’ll actually have an effect on him that gained’t permit him to nonetheless be a superb participant.”
GO DEEPER
Re-evaluating Michael Penix Jr.’s NFL Draft inventory: How good can Washington’s star QB be?
Penix will get an opportunity to showcase his expertise subsequent week for the NFL on the Senior Bowl. It’ll be the subsequent step in what figures to be a compelling course of for a quarterback who has already been by means of rather a lot.
Jeremiah described Penix as having a “reside, explosive arm” however pointed to his low left-handed launch as one thing that will make his passing seem unorthodox at first look. His expertise, in the meantime, ought to work in his favor.
“With a clear harm sheet, I’d’ve stated he’s a stand-on-the-table man simply from the best way he competes and the best way he throws, his playmaking,” Jeremiah stated. “I don’t assume the age has any issue. I’ve virtually begun to have a look at the age as a profit. He’s performed a ton, and also you’re gonna get judged Sport 1 within the NFL. I’d fairly him and Bo Nix with the 50-60 begin guys like (Brock) Purdy. They’ve gotten an opportunity to experiment, be taught, develop, make errors with out every little thing being below the microscope prefer it’s gonna be Day 1 within the NFL.”
Even when opinions are combined about his professional potential, there’s little doubt that Penix has numerous of us who’re rooting for him due to all he battled by means of in his faculty profession.
“If I’m him, I’d be tremendous proud as a result of No. 1, he persevered and got here again, and on prime of that he went to a different college and had success,” Manuel stated. “He was a baller at Indiana and he’s turn into an much more elite baller at Washington.
“Any group that will get him within the draft is getting somebody who has gone by means of adversity, which I believe is vital, but in addition an elite passer. And the throws he’s making, he’s prepared. I’d liken him to C.J. Stroud in simply how correct he’s by way of his marksmanship and means he performs soccer.”
(High photograph: Chris Graythen / Getty Photographs)
