Erik ten Hag is reportedly assured not less than one other two matches answerable for Manchester United. However past that, is there actually any hope for him long run?
For Manchester United and Erik ten Hag, there’s an unmistakable feeling the top might now be in sight. A partnership that maybe as soon as promised a lot seems to be on the precipice, with Sunday’s 3-0 humiliation by Tottenham seeing the stress arguably attain a beforehand unseen stage forward of Thursday’s journey to Porto.
Whereas Ten Hag insisted on pointing to Bruno Fernandes’ first-half pink card as a contributing consider Sunday’s defeat, United had been already 1-0 down at that time and had turned in a dismal efficiency; they had been fortunate to be solely a aim behind.
It now appears as if Ten Hag has two matches to save lots of his job. United are in Portugal within the UEFA Europa League on Thursday, earlier than taking over Aston Villa at Villa Park within the Premier League three days later. With out a dramatic turnaround of their fortunes throughout these two very robust video games, it’s hardly tough to think about United making a change throughout the worldwide break.
Whether or not that’s actually the suitable plan of action to interrupt Man Utd’s seemingly unending cycle of recent begins, who’s to say? However Ten Hag’s time in cost has been full of latest lows, and finally there comes a degree of no return.
One other Underwhelming Begin
Whereas the considerations round Ten Hag don’t simply relate to this season, United’s begin to 2024-25 seems like a wise place to start.
That is virtually as unhealthy because it’s ever been for United at first of a Premier League marketing campaign. Their haul of seven factors is the joint fewest they’ve gathered after six video games, together with 2020-21 (Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s second full season) and 2013-14 (David Moyes’ solely season), whereas solely in 2007-08 (4) have they ever scored fewer targets at this level of a season (5 in 2024-25).
That’s contributed to them having a aim distinction of -3, which is their second worst at this stage of a season after -4 in 2020-21. After all, it’s price remembering that United recovered fairly nicely in 2020-21, finally ending second within the Premier League – albeit their 74 factors would’ve solely been sufficient to complete fourth in 2023-24 and 2022-23.
Both method, such a restoration in 2024-25 could be fairly a feat, however even the possibility of a top-four end feels as if it’s shortly slipping from their attain.
Sunday’s loss to Spurs was their second consecutive Premier League house defeat with out scoring, final enduring such outcomes back-to-back at Previous Trafford in Solskjaer’s remaining two house matches on the helm in November 2021.
Additional to that, United’s 4.6 anticipated targets towards (xGA) on the weekend was their most in a single recreation in any competitors since Arsenal created 4.7 xG towards them in December 2017 – certainly, that was the notorious 3-1 win on the Emirates during which David de Gea produced the efficiency of a lifetime.
United did play a lot of the sport towards Spurs with solely 10 males following Fernandes’ unlucky pink card, for which the ban was subsequently rescinded, so there’s that caveat. Ange Postecoglou’s facet had been so superior even when it was 11v11, although.
Their prior Previous Trafford defeat was in fact to Liverpool at first of September, additionally succumbing 3-0. Having misplaced 2-1 to Brighton earlier than that, Ten Hag grew to become the primary United supervisor to lose two of the opening three video games of a Premier League season greater than as soon as.
Whereas they’ve been unfortunate in entrance of aim at instances, total it’s one other sluggish begin that calls into query the concept that they’re making any progress.
Enjoying Fashion Issues
It’s broadly accepted that Ten Hag was employed not less than partly due to the fashion of soccer his Ajax crew performed. They dominated the ball and had been attack-minded, and his arrival at Previous Trafford actually introduced pleasure a few new course on the pitch.
And there have been instances when United have seemed thrilling underneath Ten Hag, with these Europa League matches towards Barcelona in early 2023 instantly springing to thoughts.
However such cases have been much less commonplace than events of United getting totally battered.
Ten Hag did say in his very first press convention at United that the gamers out there to him must dictate the fashion to a level, however the regularity at which they’ve signed people both recognized to Ten Hag or beforehand managed by him has prompt a want to considerably recreate components of what he had at Ajax.
There could also be a concerted plan to play out from the again, and because the graphic beneath highlights, this season they seem like making a larger effort to maintain the ball for longer.
Nevertheless, the following graphic reveals how they’re nonetheless fairly far off being thought to be enjoying a “sluggish and complex” fashion of play, like Manchester Metropolis for instance.
Ten Hag’s United have principally been a transition-based crew – arguably not too dissimilar in that regard then to Solskjaer’s facet. Actually, they can’t be thought of a possession-dominant facet.
Throughout Ten Hag’s two and a bit years in cost, United’s common share of possession within the Premier League is 52.2%, lower than that of six golf equipment. And whereas that may not sound so damning, the very fact Brighton have managed 60.4% over the identical interval highlights that this isn’t unattainable.
Granted, there’s not just one approach to play; you don’t need to attempt to monopolise the ball. United have proven high quality in transition and their 241 pictures in transition was 42 greater than some other Premier League membership in 2022-23, whereas in addition they topped the charts for targets from quick breaks (9) the identical season.
However the lack of management they’ve been responsible of has so typically brought on them hurt. Solely Luton City (215) and Newcastle (208) confronted extra pictures in transition than United final time period (205), whereas United had been additionally third solely to that pair for pictures conceded following quick breaks (35).
Moreover, United’s opponents reached the ultimate third 620 instances in transition in 2023-24, greater than some other crew. Additionally they rank poorly just about throughout the board in transition/quick break metrics in 2024-25.
This all feeds into the truth that United have confronted the second-most pictures (741) within the Premier League because the begin of final season, 112 greater than they’ve tried.
Over the identical interval, groups United followers will really feel they’re obliged to be difficult have recorded comfortably extra pictures than they’ve confronted (Manchester Metropolis +470, Liverpool +412 and Arsenal +324).
The graphic beneath hammers the purpose house: too typically over the previous 12 months or so, United have been much less of a risk to their opponents’ aim than their opponents have been to theirs.
Followers will really feel that’s unacceptable for Manchester United.
The Greater Image
After all, United’s begin to 2024-25 and considerations over their enjoying fashion are a part of a broader story.
Whereas it’s not essentially one thing you may exactly quantify, some would argue United are additional away from wanting like a title-challenging crew than at some other level in Ten Hag’s tenure.
As of Thursday’s recreation towards Porto, the Dutchman may have been in cost formally for 825 days, going again to the beginning of his contract on 1 July 2022. On common, managers which have left a Premier League membership since 2014-15 (excluding present managers, interim/caretakers, and Jürgen Klopp) had been in cost for 630 days. Positive, there’s no definitive reply to how lengthy a supervisor wants and each membership’s state of affairs is completely different, however he’s had extra time than most get.
The issue is that interval has been plagued by lows, whereas supporters have seen different golf equipment appoint managers who’ve virtually instantly loved some success in implementing adjustments or a brand new fashion of play.
Sunday’s loss to Spurs was the eighth time underneath Ten Hag that United have misplaced by three or extra targets within the Premier League, with solely Gary O’Neil, David Moyes and Sean Dyche (all 9) struggling extra equally heavy defeats in that point. What makes that even worse is the very fact United have solely gained seven league video games by three or extra targets over the identical interval.
United’s 10 defeats by 3+ targets in all competitions with Ten Hag in cost is double that of some other supervisor since Alex Ferguson. Solskjaer misplaced 5, however then his United facet additionally gained by 3+ targets 30 instances, whereas the present boss has solely managed 13.
Half of Ten Hag’s defeats by 3+ targets have come at Previous Trafford (5), which is identical quantity as all different United managers post-Ferguson mixed.
After all, it’s not simply heavy defeats which have come to characterise Ten Hag’s time in cost. The 2023-24 season was a marketing campaign of unprecedented lows for them within the Premier League, ending decrease than ever earlier than in eighth and with a destructive aim distinction for the primary time.
Moreover, 58 targets conceded was their most in a single season since 1978-79 (63 – in a 42-game season) and so they suffered 14 league defeats, a brand new membership file within the Premier League period, two extra even than the crew recorded in Moyes’ ill-fated 2013-14.
It might be unfair to fully overlook the damage disaster United needed to face in 2023-24, as a result of it was important. However their type at first of 2024-25 understandably has some questioning how a lot of an influence it really made contemplating outcomes haven’t precisely improved.
There’s no magic roadmap that factors the best way in soccer, and who’s to say Ten Hag can’t flip United round finally? Possibly he would with extra time – however the level many are making is that maybe he’s had sufficient. Different managers elsewhere have proven it doesn’t essentially have to take years to rework a membership’s performances, and nobody would take a look at United’s squad and say it lacks high quality.
Whereas Ten Hag has gained two trophies, as he often factors out, that’s not essentially an important barometer of a supervisor’s efficiency; a league marketing campaign supplies a extra conclusive evaluation and United have underwhelmed within the Premier League for over a 12 months.
What different prime golf equipment would settle for being to this point in need of expectations for thus lengthy?
Get pleasure from this? Subscribe to our soccer e-newsletter to obtain unique weekly content material. You also needs to observe our social accounts over on X, Instagram, TikTok and Fb.
