Breadcrumb Path Hyperlinks
SportsHockeyNHLHockey Inside OutMontreal Canadiens
The underside line is he would not have the post-season pedigree of these whose numbers dangle from the rafters of the Bell Centre.
Article content material
Ought to Carey Value’s sweater ultimately be retired and hung from the rafters of the Bell Centre together with the jerseys of the 18 storied former Canadiens who’ve had that honour?
The very first thing to clarify is that although it looks like he’s, Value isn’t really retired. He’s technically nonetheless a Montreal Canadien however clearly he’ll by no means play one other recreation for the staff. He was on long-term injured reserve final season and presumably will probably be once more this season and subsequent, the final two years of his eight-year, $84-million contract.
Commercial 2
Article content material
His actual final hurrah was that heroic run to the Stanley Cup ultimate within the spring of 2021, a run that may not have occurred with out Value performing miracles between the pipes on a nightly foundation. He injured his knee when Chris Kreider of the New York Rangers smashed into him — deliberately or unintentionally — within the convention ultimate within the 2014 and that knee has been a difficulty for him ever since.
In the summertime of 2021, after the looks within the finals, surgeons cleansing out a torn meniscus found an osteochondral defect and so they instructed surgical procedure however Value declined, frightened about its affect on his skill to operate usually exterior of the rink.
He performed 5 video games proper close to the tip of the next season, however he clearly wasn’t capable of carry out anyplace close to optimum stage and that was it for his profession.
His injury-plagued years after the Kreider hit are a giant a part of the explanation there’s a lot debate about whether or not Value’s jersey needs to be retired. The season after the Kreider incident was Value’s finest — he gained the Vézina, Jennings and Hart trophies, together with the Ted Lindsay Award. However after that, his document was up-and-down, principally attributable to accidents.
Street to the Cup
Article content material
Commercial 3
Article content material
Does on a regular basis misplaced to accidents take him out of the dialogue for the Habs to someday retire his sweater? Not essentially. I believe the actual purpose his sweater shouldn’t be retired is his lack of playoff success. He solely introduced the Canadiens past the second spherical twice. He was on the staff that made the convention ultimate in 2010, however that was referred to as The Halak Spring for the superb purpose that Slovakian netminder Jaroslav Halak was the hero of these playoffs and Value hardly performed.
Within the convention ultimate in 2014, he was knocked out of play within the first recreation, in order that grew to become the last word what-if run for the Canadiens. Would they’ve gone to the ultimate and possibly gained the Cup if Value had stayed wholesome? We’ll by no means know. In 2021, Value did drag the staff proper to the finals, however then when he hit the largest stage of his life, he merely wasn’t ok. He stated it himself within the press convention after the ultimate recreation with the collection gained 4-1 by the Tampa Lightning.
“On the finish of the day, I simply don’t assume I performed effectively sufficient at first of the collection,” Value stated on the time.
In fact a lot of that lack of playoff success has to do with the groups in entrance of him and his normal managers have loads to reply for. However the backside line is he doesn’t have the post-season pedigree of nearly any of the gamers whose sweaters are retired. Is he actually proper up there with Maurice Richard, Jean Béliveau, Ken Dryden, and Man Lafleur? To ask the query is to reply it.
Commercial 4
Article content material
At Serge Savard’s golf match final month, Dryden mainly stated Value deserves the honour, answering a query about whether or not his sweater needs to be retired.
“I gained’t say something as a result of that’s anyone else’s choice,” Dryden stated. “However I believe the reply’s fairly clear.”
I’ve the utmost respect for Dryden as a participant — six cups in simply over seven seasons! — as an writer and a human being, however he’s mistaken on this one.
All you could know is that Jacques Lemaire’s sweater hasn’t but been retired. Lemaire’s former teammate Mario Tremblay just lately stated it’s an outrage Lemaire’s jersey hasn’t been raised to the rafters. And it’s a must to agree. Lemaire gained eight cups!
“With the variety of cups that he gained, I believe it’s unforgivable that his sweater is just not hanging from the roof of the Bell Centre,” stated Tremblay. “I hope Mr. Molson will hearken to what I simply stated.”
Lemaire definitely deserves to have his sweater hung there earlier than Value.
Followers are divided on the difficulty of retiring Value’s sweater.
“If he ever will get to the Corridor of Fame, I’d say yeah,” Ken McDonald stated on the bar in McLean’s Pub this week. “However up till that point, I don’t assume so and I don’t assume he’s a Corridor of Famer … to be trustworthy with you.”
Armin Dehghan, additionally at McLean’s Wednesday, begs to vary.
“I consider it ought to,” Dehghan stated. “He was the highest goalie of his technology. And never just for what he gave to the Montreal Canadiens however what he gave to all of the aspiring children.”
Chris Hermann, additionally a fan, agrees.
“I’m not shocked there’s a debate about it,” Hermann stated. “My private opinion is that he’s executed loads for the staff. He was the face of the staff for a while. He’s executed actually nice work. … We must always honour him as a metropolis and present that stage of respect.”
bkelly@postmedia.com
twitter.com/brendanshowbiz
Really helpful from Editorial
What the Puck: If that is the tip for Carey Value, it is a unhappy strategy to go
What the Puck: Followers nonetheless debating Carey Value’s place in Habs historical past
Commercial 5
Article content material
Article content material
Share this text in your social community
